Stories from Asimov's have won 44 Hugos and 24 Nebula Awards, and our editors have received 18 Hugo Awards for Best Editor.

Current issue also available in
various electronic formats at

Subscribe to Asimov's Science Fiction
Current Issue Anthologies Forum e-Asimov's Links Contact Us Blogs
Subscribe
View Cart

Asimovs.com :: Forum

user:
psw:
| lost password
Forum problems? Contact the administrator.
Home » General Discussion » Processed food linked to depression Messages in this topic - RSS
11/3/2009 2:09:21 PM
Madison Bridgen
Madison Bridgen
Posts 338
http://ca.news.yahoo.com/s/afp/091102/health/lifestyle_britain_health_research

Processed and greasy foods can increase depression in people by up to 58%, according to this article. So if you're feeling down, it's time to gorge on fruits and vegetables.

The only problem is that processed food tastes so much better and is easier to get a hold of. If I'm spending $5 I might as well fill up on a burger rather than 5 fruit cups that will just leave me hungry again in 20 minutes.

--
We are currently living in the Dinosaurs' post-apocalyptic world.
11/3/2009 6:53:12 PM
Marian
Posts 3065
Not if you eat fresh fruits and vegetables. The getting hungry again after eating fruit cups is that they are loaded with sugar. Sugar sends you on a brief high and then a crash where you're both hungry and depressed.

--
"Know the truth and the truth shall make you odd."
11/3/2009 7:57:17 PM
Kevin C.
Kevin C.
Posts 1686
Yes if you eat fresh fruits and vegetables. Apples make me more hungry than Chinese food, and I'm less hungry if I skip fruit at breakfast than if I eat it.

I sincerely hope the link doesn't have the full story, for the reasons given why processed foods can increase the likelihood of depression doesn't quite ring true. Were I one of the researchers, I'd start looking at the ingredients in the processed foods, then conduct a study with the same foods but with one "plain."

What constitutes processed? Freshly ground hamburger wouldn't seem to be processed, but cured ham probably is.
11/3/2009 9:51:00 PM
Marian
Posts 3065
What's wrong with being hungry, especially at breakfast? It's only wrong when it's a blood sugar crash brought on by eating too much sugar.

However, I agree with your point about how vague the article is.

--
"Know the truth and the truth shall make you odd."
11/3/2009 9:55:53 PM
pc
pc
Posts 2231
OMG, that means, if I change my diet, I'm at risk of exploding from sheer joy!

--
It is a mistake to think you can solve any major problems just with potatoes -- Douglas Adams
11/3/2009 10:55:51 PM
Kevin C.
Kevin C.
Posts 1686
Marian wrote:
What's wrong with being hungry, especially at breakfast? It's only wrong when it's a blood sugar crash brought on by eating too much sugar.


You admit that yes, fruits and vegetables can leave you hungry? As to what's wrong with being hungry, try concentrating while hungry. Or try digging post holes while hungry. Or clearing brush. Or digging a ditch with a shovel. Or changing out an overhead transformer. Try living on rabbit food and doing that.
11/3/2009 11:28:04 PM
Byron Bailey
Byron Bailey
Posts 3582
My oh my! Does this mean I should start cooking my daily dose of ramen noodles on the stove rather than the microwave?

--
Yeah, I weigh 800 pounds. All muscle. Really. Well, mostly muscle. Well, the doctor said that I had muscles -- hundreds of them.
11/3/2009 11:31:41 PM
Alex
Alex
Posts 1374
Mmmmmmmmm Cheesecake. Dowsed with a syrup made with mass quantities of homegrown Blueberries.

Pidgeonhole that!

--
We try not to let over-zealous adherance to facts interfere with the spinning of a good yarn, or a bad joke.
11/4/2009 9:16:11 AM
Madison Bridgen
Madison Bridgen
Posts 338
Vegetables are now theraputic. We can cut down on drug expenses by perscribing bananas and oranges instead of Paxil.

--
We are currently living in the Dinosaurs' post-apocalyptic world.
11/4/2009 10:30:09 AM
Bill Moonroe
Bill Moonroe
Posts 4528
Madison wrote:
Vegetables are now theraputic. We can cut down on drug expenses by perscribing bananas and oranges instead of Paxil.


Isn't Paxil what was put into the terraforming machines that sent the Reavers over the edge? Better than bananas and oranges, try licking toads and frogs.

It seems to me that the second you kill an animal, or pick a fruit or vegetable, some processing has begun. So, maybe Fidel Castro has it right with the live chicken diet, after all. Hasn't seemed to hurt him none.

--

"A thagizer? What's that do? Hey, what's this button for? Uh-oh. Sorry about that, man. It'll grow back, right?"
11/4/2009 11:28:59 AM
Madison Bridgen
Madison Bridgen
Posts 338
In it's gaseous state, Paxil can totally do that. That's why the Paxil mines of northern Quebec can be quite fatal, as they are full for workers who turned into Reavers after breaking into gas pockets deep beneith the Earth. Most of the time the Paxil can be savely refined for psychiatric use, but many of the Reavers manage to escape the mines and get into government offices.

--
We are currently living in the Dinosaurs' post-apocalyptic world.
11/4/2009 12:39:09 PM
Kevin C.
Kevin C.
Posts 1686
Going back over my reply to Marian, I was unduly snippy (and no I won't blame it on hunger). I apologize for that.

I think it says something to me that I can eat fruit and be hungry an hour later, but skip it and feel fine. I strongly suspect it's the sugars, and while complex carbohydrates generally doesn't cause this effect, it seems that fruit can still bring it about. To say hunger from sugar in junk food is bad and hunger from natural foods is good seems to miss the point that hungry is hungry regardless of the cause.
pages: 1
|

Home » General Discussion » Processed food linked to depression

View Cart



Current Issue Anthologies Forum T-shirts Links Contact Us Subscribe Privacy Statement
Search Now:
In Association with
Amazon.com

To contact us about editorial matters, send an email to Asimov's SF.
Questions regarding subscriptions should be sent to our subscription address.
If you find any Web site errors, typos or other stuff worth mentioning, please send it to the webmaster.

Copyright © 2009 Dell Magazines, A Division of Penny Publications, LLC
Current Issue Anthologies Forum Contact Us